Chabad Power Struggle Goes To Israeli Secular Court

Chabad’s warring factions have ended up in a secular court in Israel. Globes reports:

Chassidei Chabad Lubavitch Yeshiva Rosh Yeshiva Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Wilshansky, Beit Chana Schools head Rabbi Shlomo Raskin, and members of Chabad Israel, which manages the movement’s activities in the country, have petitioned the courts to prevent Tzeirei Agudat Chabad (Chabad Youth Organization in Israel) chairman Rabbi Yosef Y. Aharonov and five members of Tzeirei Chabad from taking it over.

Wilshansky and Raskin asked the court to forbid the respondents from making material changes Tzeirei Chabad’s foundation documents, signatory rights, directors, and membership, or making any other fundamental changes. The petitioners claim that this is an attempt to illegally take over Tzeirei Chabad, and through it, Chabad Israel in general.

The petitioners claim that there are grounds for concern that the respondents, headed by Aharonov, will create a fait accompli, and even withdraw money from Tzeirei Chabad or sell its assets. The petitioners are therefore seeking temporary relief.

The court was not persuaded that there is a reason for issuing the requested ex parte injunctions, and asked the respondents to file statements of defense.
Chabad’s international activities are estimated at over $1 billion a year. There are no estimates about the extent of Chabad’s activities in Israel, but they presumably amount to tens of millions of dollars a year. These activities include running several yeshivas (houses of Jewish learning), kindergartens and schools, publishing weekly newsletters about events within the Hassidic movement and outside of it, the operation of so-called “mitzvah tanks”, and hosting holiday events.

The Chabad movement has been wracked by a power struggle between moderate and messianic factions since the death of Lubavitcher Rabbi Menachem Mendel Scheerson over a decade ago. The latter factions claim that Scheerson was the Messiah. Chabad’s main institutions are run by the moderate factions, although the messianic factions run a number of institutions in Israel.

There is no dispute between the factions over Chabad’s right-wing political character. Chabad was among the top opponents of the disengagement plan and Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s government. Chabad has not yet declared which candidate it will support in the upcoming elections, but it should be remembered that it backed Benjamin Netanyahu for prime minister in 1996, under the slogan “Netanyahu is good for the Jews”.

Aharonov is the anti-public-messianism company man. Wilshansky, if memory serves me, is the opposite. Does anyone have any information to flesh this report out a bit?



Filed under Chabad Theology, Territorial Disputes

5 responses to “Chabad Power Struggle Goes To Israeli Secular Court

  1. Dovid

    You got Ahronov and Wilshansky right.

    About a year and a half ago Shlomo Madaintchek (Mishechist) the director of Agudas Chabad in Israel died. His death sparked a power struggle between the Mishecists and Antis.

  2. Shmuel

    Is there something wrong with me, or is it the case that Chasidim (Chasidim!) seem to prefer secular courts over batei din? Chabad, Satmar, Bobov..what’s up with them? Are there no rabbis capable of hearing these internal fights?

  3. Anonymous

    Aranav won in court and Beit Din. Wilshansky is the guru of zefat meshiites!

  4. Schneur

    Let Judge Rosenwasser settle this one too.
    Perhaps R. Zalman Leib Teitelbaum could become a hired hand rebbe for Lubavitch subject to contractual agreements and renewal.

  5. Dover Eimes Bilvavoy.

    the 2 litigants :
    ze neveile veze treife

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s