Rubashkin Is Not Alone

Rubashkin is not alone in his reprehensible treatment of workers. Here’s an example from a North Carolina plant owned by Smithfield Foods as reported by Bob Herbert writes in the New York Times (sorry, no direct link is available for free):

Union representation would make a big difference for Smithfield workers. The United Food and Commercial Workers Union has been trying to organize the plant since the mid-1990’s. Smithfield has responded with tactics that have ranged from the sleazy to the reprehensible.

After an exhaustive investigation, a judge found that the company had threatened to shut down the entire plant if the workers dared to organize, and had warned Latino workers that immigration authorities would be alerted if they voted for a union.

The union lost votes to organize the plant in 1994 and 1997, but the results of those elections were thrown out by the National Labor Relations Board after the judge found that Smithfield had prevented the union from holding fair elections. The judge said the company had engaged in myriad “egregious” violations of federal labor law, including threatening, intimidating and firing workers involved in the organizing effort, and beating up a worker “for engaging in union activities.”

Rather than obey the directives of the board and subsequent court decisions, the company has tied the matter up on appeals that have lasted for years. A U.S. Court of Appeals ruling just last month referred to “the intense and widespread coercion prevalent at the Tar Heel facility.”

Workers at Smithfield and their families are suffering while the government dithers, refusing to require a mighty corporation like Smithfield to obey the nation’s labor laws in a timely manner.

The defiance, greed and misplaced humanity of the merchants of misery at the apex of the Smithfield power structure are matters consumers might keep in mind as they bite into that next sizzling, succulent morsel of Smithfield pork.

Two wrongs don’t make a right. Even if Smithfield is worse than Rubashkin, both are still wrong. If Smithfirld were producing kosher meat, I would urge you to boycott its products, just as I have urged you to boycott Rubashkin. (My assumption is none of you, at least none of the Jews who read this blog, are consuming pork products – for those of you readers who may be, please don’t buy Smithfield.)

[Hat tip: Brooklyn Cowboy.]



Filed under Kosher Business?, Kosher Meat Scandal

6 responses to “Rubashkin Is Not Alone

  1. Ploni Ben Ploni


    Whats your issue with Rubashkin? are you so jealous that his family made it and living it up, while your winning on a stupid Blog?

  2. Stephen Mendelsohn


    If you read the full article, you would notice that Smithfield (described by Matthew Scully, author of Dominion, as the most savage corporation in America toward people and animals alike) pays its lowest paid workers over $8 an hour to start, or nearly a third more than Rubashkin does. That is, we may have found in AgriProcessors the one company even more cruel than Smithfield, and that is a tall order.

  3. Stephen Mendelsohn


    The original New York Times article was reprinted by the Organic Consumers Association:

  4. Nigritude Ultramarine

    Rubashkin may not be alone in how they treat people, but they have the singular distinction of being a “religious” enterprise that’s involved in such disgusting behavior.

  5. Nigritude Ultramarine

    are you so jealous that his family made it and living it up

    Just because things seem to be going your way, doesn’t mean you are doing the right thing. Try learning sometime.

  6. hashfanatic

    If everyone hates the status quo, and there are those who still defend the status quo, it’s a sure bet they they are themselves dependent on the status quo (and everything that entails).

    Money, power, security, even a shot at everlasting life. That’s pretty heady stuff.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s