Yeshiva and Day School Parents Band Together; Rabbis, Administrators Have Failed In Their Duties

The New York Jewish Week reports:

A tangle of hot-button issues — from rabbis allegedly molesting children to the staggering cost of day-school tuition to lax school security — is suddenly confronting yeshivas today.

And some parents, having complained about a lack of accountability by those who run and manage Orthodox yeshivas and day schools, are banding together to demand answers.

Last Sunday night, a group of about 15 parents gathered at the Young Israel of Long Beach for an inaugural meeting of the New York State Yeshiva Parents Association, which represents perhaps the first effort by yeshiva and day school parents to organize. Hosted by Elliot Pasik, a lawyer from Long Beach with five kids in the yeshiva system, the meeting attracted parents who have grown frustrated with various aspects of how private Jewish schools are operated.

“We Jews are wonderful thinkers and teachers, but we’re sometimes less good at the actual mechanics of operating a school and we shouldn’t be shy about asking the government to help us,” said Pasik.

Pasik said that over the past couple of years he has grown increasingly concerned about the discrepancy between the standards for public and private schools as well as the private schools’ seeming unwillingness to address some security concerns.

“Defibrillators are required in the public schools, but not in non-public schools. That makes no sense to me,” he said, citing an example. “It makes no sense that if you have a complaint against a public school employee you can complain to the state education department, but that that is not so for the private schools. The lack of statewide discipline encourages a climate of doing whatever they want — slapping a child or worse.”

Pasik has succeeded in partially closing at least one such gap. He recently fought for and won a New York State law that enables private schools to conduct background fingerprinting checks to determine whether a prospective employee has a criminal history. Previously, private schools were allowed only to do more limited checks. Public schools have been obliged to conduct background fingerprint checks for the past few years.

However, other efforts have not been as successful. Earlier this year, for example, Pasik said he represented a couple of former students from Yeshiva & Mesivta Torah Temimah of Flatbush who claimed they had been molested by Rabbi Yehuda Kolko. However, when Pasik asked for a rabbinical court to adjudicate, he was denied.

Meanwhile, since Rabbi Kolko, like many private school teachers, was not state certified, the alleged victims could not file their complaints with the state. The former students, now both adults, have sued the school and the rabbi, who has been put on administrative leave. The lawsuits are pending.

Such experiences convinced Pasik that “there has to be a neutral, unbiased forum that a child or parent with a grievance can go to. The government has to legally require that. A non-public school child should not feel less secure.”…

In a related issue in the same report, two of the parents involved in the Orthodox takeover of the Lawrence, NY school board make it clear critics were correct in their attacks on the move:

…Two of the people in attendance recently spearheaded a controversial effort to get an Orthodox majority on the Lawrence school board. That move, which succeeded, was designed to enable the board to attempt to get more financial support for private schools, namely by using public school teachers to teach secular studies in the private schools.

Jonathan Isler, one of the two men involved in that effort, said that now that four out of seven board members are Orthodox and that more than half of all Lawrence students attend private schools, there is a good chance that this effort will succeed. If it does, he said, the issue will likely wind up in the courts.

If public school teachers are eventually used to teach secular studies in the private schools, Isler, who sends his children to The Hebrew Academy of the Five Towns and Rockaway (HAFTR) estimated that the cost of a yeshiva or day school education — which can exceed $20,000 a year for high school — could be cut by 30 to 40 percent while the quality of secular studies could improve since public school teachers are state certified. …

In other words, take millions of dollars out of the public school system and put the money into private education, just what critics feared.

[Hat tip: JWB.]



Filed under Crime, Haredim, Jewish Leadership, Modern Orthodoxy

5 responses to “Yeshiva and Day School Parents Band Together; Rabbis, Administrators Have Failed In Their Duties

  1. Shmarya, you’re all wrong on this.

    The Isler plan, which I blogged about extensively when it was first proposed, was actually openly supported by the public school community and administration. (Not that you can nevessarily take that at face value, but nevertheless…) This was NOT an attempt to funnel public school dollars into private schools, but more a proposal (which the public schools out here as well as the local teacher’s union publicly claimed to be on board with) that would, in some minds, revitalize the dwindling public school population, as well as lower costs for private school parents. That said, I and many other locals have been doubtful since this plan’s inception that it would ever succeed – the church/state conflicts just seem insurmountable.

    Another point you seem to miss (though it’s not your fault – the Jewish Week, as usual, makes hash of the reporting) is that this proposal was thought up quite some time ago – well before the school board was “taken over” by the Orthodox. Also to categorize the two proposers as “parents involved in the Orthodox takeove of the Lawrence school board” is simply an assertion that is not borne out by the facts given in the article. How in the world do you know that the two men in question even voted for the Orthodox takeover of the board? A community like Lawrence is far from monolithic in our voting patterns. There are always those who buck the trend, and you have no way of knowing whether these two you refer to have done so.

    I think you have put two and two together here and come up with five.

  2. Not much to add to OM’s comment, but as she notes, part of the problem is that the JW gets its facts wrong:

    That move [i.e., getting an Orthodox majority on the board], which succeeded, was designed to enable the board to attempt to get more financial support for private schools, namely by using public school teachers to teach secular studies in the private schools.

    What nonsense. Isler’s plan was a complete dead letter by the time of the election and played no role in the campaign. What probably happened here is the JW, based on its prior reporting on the Isler plan, was fooled into thinking that Isler had something to do with the election, when in fact that was not the case. In fact, the two things have nothing to do with each other.

    However, putting that aside, how is a plan to have public school teachers teach yeshivia children funnelling money into private education? The move would hurt the yeshivas the most by taking away their secular education program. The beneficiaries here would have been (aside from the private school parents) the public school teachers.

  3. hashfanatic

    Just another rape of the American taxpayer.

    Thank you, Nassau County.

  4. noclue

    Yes. How horrible. These vile Orthodox parents want their kids to get a good secular education. And, they want equal rights. They want the state to pay for it through their tax dollars just as the state now pays for the secular education of non Jewish-Orthodox parents, some of whom pay no taxes at all and others who have no legal right to be in this country. The nerve of them!

    What will they do next? Vote in non-school board elections for candidates who represent their best (including financial, Lo Aleinu) interest? Stop them now before this vile perversion of the democratic process undermines American democracy and morality itself! Take away their right to vote, NOW!

  5. avrohom

    May shmarya and his friends do teshuva, andinstead of working to destroy Jewish education may he and his friends appreciate that only if Jewish and ORthox and Haredi schools will flourish can Judaism continue and instead of cirticizing attempts to alleviate the burden of Orthodox Jews to bleed for paying so dearly for the education of their offsprings whereas others have the choice for free education (and Jews do not have this option) he actually make a resolution that the coming year of 5767 be ayear of no bashing of his jewish brothers and for finding ingenous ways to ease the burden of his brethern to Jewish education.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s