Rabbi Elyashiv on Kosher Slaughter

The ever helpful Internet edition of the Israeli Yated Ne’eman, controlled by Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, has this to say about the rabbi’s position on shechita:

Recently a number of prominent members of the Jewish community in Germany met with members of an animal rights organization, telling them that the halochoh does not permit stunning the animal before shechitoh. The animal rights advocates said they would be willing to compromise by allowing local anesthesia of the neck using a special spray rather than by injection. The kehilloh members then asked HaRav Jakob to consult on the matter with Maran HaRav Eliashiv.

Maran replied that there is no way of knowing whether this type of anesthesia affects the animal’s viability, making it impossible to clearly determine whether the animal has been rendered a neveiloh or treifoh. Maran also said, "How do we know? The non-Jews may draw other conclusions from this with regard to Jewish shechitoh. They may draw inferences with regard to other things, if it appears to them that Jews are prepared to loosen shechitoh requirements. This could lead to further problems.

"Everything is cause for concern," said HaRav Eliashiv. "Even if it can be argued that it is theoretically permissible according to halochoh, we cannot change accepted practices and the [traditional] shechitoh practices must remain and should not be touched in the slightest."

When told the Jews of Germany have to work very hard to find kosher meat and the difficulty they have leads many Jews to eat non-kosher meat, Maran replied, "Jews work hard in every place over everything, but when legitimization is given to such a thing nobody knows where it could lead. Therefore one must not agree to it."

Apparently Rubashkin’s throat-ripping with a meat hook was part of the long haredi tradition of "accepted practices." But wait! You’ve never heard of such a practice before Rubashkin came up with it? No meat hook to the throat 5 seconds after the shechita cut and while the animal was fully conscious?

No, silly – not that practice. The practice of bending halakha for under the table cash and, when getting caught, claiming the throat-ripping or whatever as part of the time-honored haredi tradition.

[Hat Tip: The Good Doctor Filosof.]



Filed under Haredim, Kosher Meat Scandal

10 responses to “Rabbi Elyashiv on Kosher Slaughter

  1. Yos

    Long story short, unless you eat meat that you (assuming you’re a genuinely qualified Shochet) yourself have cultivated, you’re eating trash. So what’s new?

    I think the Amish have it right here. Jewish agriculture has gone to hell. Literally. You can do shechita on a conveyor belt.

  2. Yos

    Can’t do, CAN’T. Dur.

  3. der yid

    I attended the debate wed evening, thanks to your post. Stam, Rubashken stopped the throat ripping.

  4. He stopped the throat-ripping after the USDA threatend to shut him down, that after PETA outed him and the USDA’s coverup.

    And, as many who have dealt w/Rubashkin will testify, you can’t trust him. Ever.

  5. Anonymous

    When Shmarya started to become frum, he wanted a shiduch with Rubashkin’s sister, they refused. that’s where all the hate comes from, it has NOTHING to do with anumal rights.

  6. Are you nuts? I never even heard of Rubashkin until 5 years after I became frum, and his sister’s were all married for years by then. You Chabadniks are really sick.

  7. Neo-Conservaguy

    So, how was the debate between the shill for Postville and the radicals from PETA? Is there any press coverage, or even better, video?

  8. Hope to have a tape up late in the week or early next …

  9. Central Rabbinical Council

    At a meeting with the leading Rabbanim in regards to the MEAL MART/ALLE PROCESSING story, it was concleded that there is no problem whatsoever with the process of NIKUR in their meats,it was also concluded that this whole fiasco was engineered by an evil person with a personnal AGENDA against MEAL MART it was decided by the Rabbis to publish this evil person’s name: his name is [edited by siteowner] Please announce this evil person’s name all over.

  10. Aarnon

    The Maran, may be an expert on halachic law, but it is big mistake to extand that knowledge elsewhere. HaShem gave us reason and perception that would better discover him.

    It would be very easy to do a scientific experiment to verify that applying local anesthetic does not affect the conciousness of the animal.

    Has no Rav ever had dental work or minor surgery done?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s