Haredi Rabbinic Leaders Still Oppose Work

Ynet reports:

In an effort to encourage more haredi adults to join the workforce the first of six ultra-orthodox oriented job placement centers was dedicated in Jerusalem Wednesday. The five remaining centers are expected to open their doors for haredi communities throughout the country in the near future.

The Joint (American Joint Jewish Distribution Committee – JDC), which is backing the project along with the state, has been involved in integrating the ultra-Orthodox community into the workforce since 1996. So far some USD 10,500,000 has been invested in the initative, with almost 2,000 new workers enrolling in the various training programs.…

One of the applicants is Shira Nardi, a 21 year old ultra-Orthodox woman who attended secretarial school and now hopes to find employment through the center. She describes the change undergone by the haredi community in regards to employment as "a revolution." "Everything’s been cut back, you can’t live off of what you get anymore," said Shira, attributing the extreme change to the reduction of government stipends for child support.

The ‘revolution’ however is far from complete as more than a few Rabbis voice there concern over the change. "It’s hard to say that all the Rabbis are encouraging employment," said Flintstein who acknowledges that there are still setbacks to overcome, "but certainly is a man reaches a situation where he has difficulty supporting (his family) then he must go to work. He is told to do this and not remain in his current situation."

Understand this well. If a man can no longer live on welfare and other handouts, then and only then should he seek work. Otherwise he must continue to learn all day and may not enter the workforce. This is confirmed by the Belzer Rebbe’s position, which is among the more permissive of haredi leaders:

The only Rabbi who has publicly addressed the issue is the Rebbe of Belz, Rabbi Issachar Dov Rokach who last year called on his followers to obtain a profession and encouraged them to joint the workforce under certain conditions. He said, however, that unmarried women were not to work. After marriage they may work since the burden of supporting the family falls on their shoulders. The men must of course study Torah throughout the day.

Non-haredi Jews have paid $10.5 million US dollars to educate, train and find jobs for a bunch of people whose rabbinic leaders oppose their entry into the workforce. Also note that only Netanyahu’s budget cuts forced the little positive change seen. If you want to increase that change, stop funding any haredi yeshivot, seminaries or schools, and especially stop funding the gedolim. The fish stinks from its head. To save the body, that head must be (non-violently) cut off and properly disposed of.



Filed under Haredim, Israel

4 responses to “Haredi Rabbinic Leaders Still Oppose Work

  1. Yos

    Legitimate income is so… goyishe.

    Let’s see, they live in settlements (trailer parks), they live on welfare, they marry cousins…

    If it wasn’t for that whole literacy thing and disdain for banjos, Haredi culture in Israel would look a lot like the typical evangelical American backwater.

  2. Yochanan Lavie

    Most evangelicals work. The Protestant work ethic encourages that.

  3. shmuel bet

    Did you get a report of R’ Matisyahu’s speach last night? He spoke about how people on the internets are focusing on a few failures, when the leadership has taken care of thousand of problems quietly.
    They had hookups all around the country, and the tapes are available for purchase.

  4. Isa

    How much does it cost to attend a typical heredi yesiva? I am not talking about a place like YU that offers secular degrees.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s