Haredi Rabbis and Haredi Thugs: Is There Really Any Difference?

A haredi thug, leader of a gang of haredi thugs who terrorize the Mea Shearim neighborhood of Jerusalem, is convicted of crimes of violence against another haredi gang. The reason for the violence? A war over pashkvellim, the notorious wall posters that line the neighborhood. The thug is sentence by a shomer shabbat judge to house arrest, and must wear a monitoring bracelet 24 hours a day, 7 days a week – including Shabbat. The thug and his rabbis – including the leaders of Badatz Yerushalayim-Edah Haredit, major Lithuanian ‘gedolim,’ the Ashenazi Chief Rabbi, and even a Chabad rabbi – oppose the monitoring bracelet on religious grounds, arguing it is a violation of their freedom of religion to force this criminal to "violate" Shabbat by wearing it.

But the highly respected Zomet Institute, which deals with the interface of modern technology and halakha, ruled the bracelet is permissible to wear on Shabbat. (For this, the head of the institute has received threats from – anonymous haredi thugs.)

Matthew Wagner of the Jerusalem Post reports:

… In a letter to Internal Security Minister Avi Dichter, MK Meir Porush (United Torah Judaism) called the use of the bracelet on Shabbat "anti-religious coercion."

"Zomet’s approval of the use of the bracelet on Shabbat is, of course, baseless from a halachic perspective," said Porush. "Halacha forbids the use of an instrument that causes [electronic] currents on a computer on Shabbat," he added.

Rabbi Haim Kanyevsky, one of the most respected in the Lithuanian community, ruled by proxy that use of the monitoring system on Shabbat was prohibited.

Metzger, quoting Kanyevsky, Rabbi Moshe Yehuda Leib Landau, and Rabbi Tuvia Weiss, head of the Edah Haredit’s Rabbinic Court, joined the opposition against the monitoring system. However, none of the rabbis explained why the Zomet Institute’s halachic opinion was wrong.

In contrast, Zomet’s Rosen explained why he permitted the use of the bracelet. "In the prisoner’s house there is an electronic receiver that constantly receives broadcasts from the ankle bracelet," explained Rosen.

"The prisoner’s movements do not activate anything. As long as the prisoner does not leave the perimeters of the house he remains within broadcast range of the electronic receiver and no alarm is activated. There is no difference between the ankle bracelet and any conventional battery-powered wrist watch."

Rosen added that it was possible to deactivate the bracelet without removing it, if a prisoner had permission to do so.…

If so, why did these rabbis (including Landau, who is Chabad, and Yona Metzger, the scandal-ridden chief rabbi) rule against it? Maybe because of this:

Rosen said that he had received anonymous phone calls attacking him for
rebelling against the rabbis. "But nobody bothered to find out how the
monitoring system really works," he said.

Another reason may be that Zomet is a Religious Zionist institution and haredim a virulently anti-Zionist. Predictably, the consequences of trying to enforce the law when dealing with these haredim are violent:

Haredi sources predicted that if the court refuses Zarbiv’s request, extensive haredi demonstrations against what they perceive as a violation of Zarbiv’s religious freedom will break out in Jerusalem and Beit Shemesh.

Supporters have already vented their anger over Zarbiv’s predicament. On Friday, December 29, Zarbiv forcibly removed the bracelet. Moked 99, a private security company that operates the house-arrest monitoring system for the police, responded immediately. Officers from the security company confronted a crowd of angry haredim that surrounded the patrol car, turned it on its side, and slashed all four tires.

Apparently, violent beatings of political opponents, destruction of property, threats and other violence are permitted under haredi understanding of Jewish law.

This really is Orthodox Judaism. Run away from it as fast as you can.


Filed under Bans, Crime, Haredim, Israel

10 responses to “Haredi Rabbis and Haredi Thugs: Is There Really Any Difference?

  1. LT

    This really is Orthodox Judaism. Run away from it as fast as you can.

    Left Wing Modern Orthodox Jews have almost nothing in common with these people. Do you need to grossly stereotype others and lump together groups with wildly divergent views to try and make your point?

  2. Left wing MO is dying. It’s shrinking by the second. Most of MO is closer to haredim than to Chovvevei Torah.

  3. David M. Frost

    Fine, the bracelet violates halakha. The man should have the option of serving out the rest of his sentence in prison, where the bracelet would be unnecessary.

  4. Anonymous

    he is going to prison he stands up for what he believes in not like scotty and his minions who just rant on the net

  5. B”H
    In my humble opinion the thugs who beat up other Jews at Amonah or Gush Katif are in fact worse than these ones for these ones are misguided while those who follow orders of the government to do immoral things contrary to Torah are wicked.

  6. satyaman

    >>>Apparently, violent beatings of political opponents, destruction of property, threats and other violence are permitted under haredi understanding of Jewish law>>>

    I am not sure if you are literal here or just being critical of the violence of the cheredi herds. If you are being literal I would love to see opinions by the cheredi leadership, responsa, or halacha that allows violence under these kind of circumstances

  7. LT

    Left wing MO is dying. It’s shrinking by the second. Most of MO is closer to haredim than to Chovvevei Torah.


    Since when has numbers been an indicator of truth? A person should do what they believe is right, regardless of how unpopular it is and regardless of whether their movement is growing or dying. In either case, it is still intellectually dishonest to lump Left Wing Modern Orthodoxy together with Charedim and pretend there is no difference between the two.

  8. BTA

    Why don’t they just remove the bracelet… and throw the chareidi loser in jail instead?

  9. JewishCynic

    “David Frost” and “BTA” are right. If he doesn’t want to wear the bracelet he should sit in jail. Frankly if this “frum yid” was really concerned about shabbat he should have asked to be put in jail on shabbat – what a kiddush hashem to sacrifice a day’s freedom for shabbat. But I forgot these jerks expect everyone else to sacrifice so they can live in comfort and trumpet their “holier than thou” status.
    If they keep it up, the tax paying, army serving M.O. and chiloni Israelis will leave and the haredi can try taking their aggression out on the arabs.

  10. Let’s put the shoe on the other foot. Imagine the fallout if a hiloni had beaten up a haredi thug or thugs, even in self defense.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s